Leases & Leasing Information

Equipment Leasing Blunders That Can Cost Your Firm a Mint


Rod McHenry, the financial vice president of a document imaging company, thought he had great cause for celebrating. He had signed an unbelievable $370,000 lease proposal covering computer servers, workstations, software and other networking equipment. McHenry believed he had snared an incredible lease rate, capping off weeks of negotiating an acceptable equipment price with the equipment vendor. The proposal guaranteed a lease closing and offered a return of the 2% 'commitment fee' paid by McHenry's company if the leasing company failed to give credit approval within two weeks. Little did McHenry know that signing this proposal would lead his company into the 'Twilight Zone' of equipment leasing. Ultimately, his firm would fork out more than $15,000 in legal fees seeking lessor performance, only to learn that the lessor was already insolvent and mired in several similar lawsuits.

Like McHenry's employer, thousands of U.S. companies lease equipment each year, many of them without careful attention to potential blunders. Rod McHenry became victim to one possible pitfall, but there are several areas deserving careful attention.

Falling For the Lowest Rate

One potential pot-hole facing many would-be lessees is basing their lease decision solely on the lowest monthly payment. Even on the face of it, making a decision based on the monthly payment makes little sense. First, these amounts give only a partial picture of total lease pricing. An accurate discounting of cash flows using a present value analysis, including up-front lease payments, monthly payments, security deposits and fees can often change the outcome of the lowest lease bid. Making sure that each lease proposal is reduced to a present value calculation guarantees that you will be comparing apples to apples. Even if you make accurate price comparisons, pricing all by itself fails to consider several important factors - ones that might save you a bundle in the long run and keep your firm from blundering. To avoid pitfalls in this area, list and evaluate your top priorities for a leasing arrangement. Consider factors such as: choosing the right leasing partner, balance sheet considerations, tax considerations, choosing the right form of lease, avoiding severe lease terms, and getting enough lease flexibility.

Failing to Check Lessors' References and Financial Condition

As Rod McHenry discovered, perhaps the area with the greatest potential for a misstep is lessor selection. Failing to investigate and make a wise choice of leasing partner can result in transaction delay, misrepresentations, nonperformance, unexpected fees or even fraud. Like many industries, equipment leasing encompasses many players with varying degrees of experience, specialization, integrity and financial strength. In selecting the best leasing partner, get sufficient information from bidders to perform an effective reference check. If possible, also obtain financial information from bidding lessors to evaluate their financial condition. Obtain Dunn and Bradstreet reports on each bidder. Ask for and check customer, vendor, bank and trade references. Perform an Internet news and message board search to make sure the bidding lessors are not the subject of any unresolved problems or scandals. Most reputable lessors belong to one of the major equipment leasing trade associations (ELA, EAEL, UAEL, or NAELB). Call the appropriate association for a reference. Lastly, ask around. Check with your attorney, accounting firm, banker, friends and associates who are able to make recommendations based on past experiences.

Not Fully Understanding the Lease Agreement

Failing to read and understand the major terms and conditions of the equipment lease can cost your company a bundle. While most lease agreements include similar terms and conditions, there can be noticeable differences. For example, most agreements cover the lessee's responsibility to pack the equipment and ship it to the lessor at the end of the lease, if the lessee chooses to return the equipment. Some leases require the lessee to have this done by the last day of the lease, perhaps depriving the lessee of a week or more of use. Also, some agreements require the lessee to pay for equipment de-installation, packing and shipping to any destination within the US, which can be costly. You can save money by negotiating many of these points. Read the lease agreement thoroughly, get legal advice if necessary, and negotiate points that can save you money.

Making the Wrong Choice Between Fair Market Value and Bargain Purchase Leases

High on the list of potential leasing blunders is choosing the wrong form of lease for your planned use of the equipment. Failure to choose wisely can result in significant additional lease expense. Equipment leases fall into two broad categories: 1) leases designed to pass ownership of the equipment to the lessee at the end of the lease (bargain purchase/capital leases) and 2) leases intended to allow the leasing company to retain ownership of the equipment (FMV or operating leases).

If you plan to keep the equipment beyond the term of the lease, it is generally cheaper to enter into a bargain purchase/capital lease. During the lease, you pay the lessor a rate of return plus the cost of the equipment. At the end of the lease, you receive the equipment title for a nominal payment. If the equipment is subject to rapid obsolescence or if you feel confident that you will return the equipment at the end of the lease, a FMV or operating lease might prove advantageous. What you are getting in a FMV or operating lease is the flexibility to kick the equipment out at lease end. Additionally, this form of lease can lower your lease rate as the lessor passes a portion of the anticipated residual value back to your firm in the form of lower payments. If your firm has reason to minimize liabilities appearing on the balance sheet, perhaps due to bank financial covenants, an operating lease might be appealing. In these lease situations, balance sheet concerns may trump the desire to obtain the lowest lease rate. In choosing a lease form, look at the period of intended equipment use, the potential for equipment obsolescence, balance sheet considerations, income tax considerations and any other factors that might influence lease choice.

Failing to Evaluate Vendor Service - Equipment Lease Arrangements

Entering into a 'hell or high water' equipment lease involving proprietary equipment required for a multi-year service (such as alternative energy or telephone services) can lead your firm into a situation ripe for blunder. Even under the best of circumstances, a 'hell or high water' equipment lease (one requiring non-cancelable payments) entered into in connection with a service arrangement carries a certain degree of risk. In many cases, the lease is provided by a leasing company independent from the service provider or later sold by the service provider to a lessor. The potential pitfall results from the possibility that your company might get stuck making lease payments for equipment it can no longer use, should the service provider fail or cease to offer the service. The best protection against this potential pitfall is to avoid these types of arrangements. If you must enter into such an arrangement, make sure the service provider is financially sound, reputable, and has a long track record of providing excellent service. Also, since these transactions always carry some risk, make sure that an abrupt interruption in the service will not have a material negative impact on your company or cause financial hardship.

Ignoring End-of-lease Notice Deadline

While not a deadly blunder, failing to give timely notice at the end of your lease can create significant additional lease expense for your firm if you plan to return the equipment. Many leases have provisions that require the lessee to notify the lessor of the lessee's decision to return the equipment at the end of the lease. If you violate the notice period, the lease kicks into an often unfavorable automatic renewal period, usually one to six months. If you intend to return the equipment at lease end, make sure your firm gives notice on time. It can save your firm a bundle in avoidable lease expense.

Underestimating Time Required to Close Lease

Not allowing enough time to go through the lease planning, proposal, approval and documentation phases can result in extra cost. A rushed process can lead to poor lessor selection, approval delays, documentation miscues or poorly negotiated lease terms. Except in small ticket transactions (under $ 75,000 to $ 100,000) where personal guarantees of the principals are involved, most lease transactions take at least three weeks or more to close. While some of the time is consumed in the bidding and credit review processes, much of it can be eaten up by administrative matters. Obtaining insurance certificates, filing UCC financing statements, reviewing and negotiating the lease agreement, all contribute to the time it takes to get to a lease closing. The best way to manage the lease closing process and to save precious time and money is to plan ahead. Make sure you establish criteria for the lease you are seeking, prepare a package containing information all bidders would want, obtain a lease closing list from each lease bidder, and respond to all requests/questions raised by bidding lessors on a timely basis.

While equipment leasing pitfalls can not always be avoided, you can take steps to prevent snags that can cost your firm a mint. Plan ahead and do your homework before launching the lease bidding process. Give high priority to selecting an experienced lease provider with high integrity and good expertise. Also, with lease transactions that represent significant obligations for your firm, engage a competent attorney to help you review and negotiate the equipment lease.

George Parker is a Director and Executive Vice President of Leasing Technologies International, Inc. ("LTI"), responsible for LTI's marketing and financing efforts. A co-founder of LTI, Mr. Parker has been involved in secured lending and equipment financing for over twenty years. Mr. Parker is an industry leader, frequent panelist and author of several articles pertaining to equipment financing.

Headquartered in Wilton, CT, LTI is a leasing firm specializing nationally in direct equipment financing and vendor leasing programs for emerging growth and later-stage, venture capital backed companies. More information about LTI is available at: http://www.ltileasing.com .

  


MORE RESOURCES:

Willis Lease Declares Preferred Dividend of $0.075 Per Share
MarketWatch (press release)
NOVATO, Calif., May 25, 2012 (GlobeNewswire via COMTEX) -- Willis Lease Finance Corporation (NASDAQ:WLFC) , a leading lessor of commercial jet engines, today announced that its board of directors has declared the regular monthly cash dividend for its ...

and more »


Spinnaker Thriving in a Slow Economy With Major Lease Deals in Connecticut and ...
Albany Times Union
1.4 Million SF of Space Leased Since Real Estate Correction Including Major Deals with NBC Sports, Chelsea Piers, Gartner Inc. and WWE Despite a sluggish economy and a slowly improving commercial real estate leasing market, Spinnaker Real Estate ...

and more »


GlobeSt.com

House Representatives Warn FASB About Lease Accounting
GlobeSt.com
WASHINGTON, DC-The ongoing--and now seriously delayed—efforts by the International Accounting Standards Board and its US equivalent, the Financial Accounting Standards Board, to converge lease accounting standards has caught the attention of two ...
Sherman and Campbell Lead Effort To Stop New Accounting Rules For LeasesVan Nuys News Press
Congressmen Urge FASB to Reconsider Lease Accounting ChangesAccounting Today

all 8 news articles »


Ventas Announces New Lease with Kindred
MarketWatch (press release)
The new LTAC Lease covers all ten LTACs whose lease term is currently scheduled to expire on April 30, 2013. The new LTAC Lease has an initial term of ten years and contains annual CPI-based escalations ranging from zero to 4 percent.
Senior Housing Finance Activity: HFF, Ventas, Oak Grove Capital, & MoreSenior Housing News

all 10 news articles »


Swapalease.com Honors American Heroes with Deep Discounts for Memorial Day
MarketWatch (press release)
But how about a sale that could help you swap your current lease for another summertime symbol - such as a snazzy new-to-you convertible? Beginning this Friday, May 25, Swapalease.com will help American veterans do just that with their first Memorial ...
Swapalease.com Survey Finds Drivers Sticking Close to Home Memorial Day WeekendPR Newswire (press release)

all 16 news articles »


Rogers asks BLM to delay lease auction of forest land
Anniston Star
Mike Rogers, R-Saks, Thursday asked the federal Bureau of Land Management to halt plans to lease 43000 acres of national forest land in Alabama for potential oil and natural gas drilling. Rogers said Thursday following a Calhoun County Commission ...



FDIC Signs Lease In Lakecrest
Memphis Daily News
By Sarah Baker Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. has inked a substantial lease in Lakecrest III, marking the market's largest office lease signing this year. FDIC has leased 32306 square feet in Lakecrest III, 6060 E. Primacy Parkway.

and more »


Silverdale Centre retail units leasing fast
New Zealand Herald
By Colin Taylor Only six retail units remain to be leased in the new Silverdale shopping centre, which is due to open mid-October in the Rodney district north of Auckland. The 36-unit Silverdale Centre, at 40 Hibiscus Coast Highway, with The Warehouse ...



Anytime Fitness Signs Lease for a New Club at Chandler Plaza in Chandler, Arizona
Sacramento Bee
For leasing information, please call (310) 717-6932 or visit http://www.officespacechandleraz.com/. This press release was issued through eReleases® Press Release Distribution. For more information, visit http://www.ereleases.com.

and more »


The Hindu

SC stays quashing of lease of Jal Mahal to private firm
The Hindu
The Supreme Court on Friday stayed the Rajasthan High Court order cancelling the lease of 100-acre land having historical Jal Mahal and Man Sagar Lake in Jaipur to a private firm to develop as a tourist resort. A bench of justices Deepak Verma and SJ ...
SC stays quashing of lease of Jal Mahal to pvt firmIBNLive.com

all 18 news articles »

Google News

Article List | Index | Site Map
All logos, trademarks and articles on this site are property and copyright of their respective owner(s).
The comments are property of their posters, all the rest is Copyright © 2006 CanadaSEEK.com - All Rights Reserved.